IESE Insight
Why curbing tax avoidance doesn’t result in more competitive markets
Laws against tax avoidance don’t reduce industry leaders’ dominance, nor do they encourage business creation.
In recent years, taxing large multinationals has been a major topic of international political and economic debate. Organizations such as the OECD, the IMF and the European Commission argue that combating tax avoidance increases tax revenue and can reduce industry concentration by leveling the playing field between multinationals and their smaller competitors.
This argument has influenced initiatives such as the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) project of the OECD and the G20. But does closing loopholes for tax avoidance actually reduce market concentration?
A study by IESE Prof. Martin Jacob, along with John Gallemore, Jesse Marangoni and Christian P.H. Peters, tests that premise by comparing data from economies at different stages of rollout of the BEPS project. By comparing countries that already had stricter rules with others that took a major regulatory leap forward against tax avoidance, they observed how market concentration evolves in markets subject to tighter anti-tax-avoidance regulations.
The authors, who use data from publicly traded and private companies in 17 European countries between 2010 and 2020, conclude that the reforms significantly reduce tax avoidance, but that this lower level of tax avoidance does not translate into less concentrated markets.
According to the study, concentration is reduced only when two specific factors coincide. One is a significant presence of multinationals; the other is that market leaders already had a substantial tax advantage over their rivals before the reforms.
But even in these cases, the effect is modest: The decline in industry concentration is about half of what the U.S. Department of Justice considers significant, a threshold lower than that applied by the EU.
Why don’t measures against tax avoidance curb concentration?
The study identifies three side effects of the tax reforms that point to possible explanations:
- Smaller companies may suffer more. The study finds that corporate concentration is increasing in the travel and security services sectors, both of which are dominated by a few multinationals. In these industries, smaller companies actually suffer more from the new anti-tax-avoidance regulations, losing ground to leading multinationals that absorb the tax hikes without losing market share.
- The entry of new firms is reduced. Stricter anti-tax-avoidance rules are associated with a decline in new firm entries of about 0.6% of the business population. Greater tax complexity can discourage business creation, because rules such as exit taxes or controlled foreign company (CFC) rules also affect smaller companies. Furthermore, industry giants do not experience a significant decline in their margins or profitability, whereas profits of smaller companies decline across the business sector.
- Large buyers are gaining influence in M&As. Following the new stricter anti-tax-avoidance rules, the number of M&A transactions decreased, both among companies making acquisitions and those being acquired. However, the total value of deals has remained steady, which is driven by increasingly large buyers. Put differently, when anti-tax-avoidance rules tighten, the largest companies continue to acquire firms to build strength, while smaller ones have stopped making acquisitions, widening the competitive gap.
Taxation and competition are two separate challenges
The study does not question that combating tax avoidance is important, and indeed confirms that the reforms help reduce it.
However, in contrast to the claims by policymakers, the authors cast doubt on whether tax policy can effectively create more equitable markets. If the goal is to reduce industry concentration in the economy, policymakers will instead need to design measures specifically for that purpose, such as stricter enforcement of antitrust laws.
ALSO OF INTEREST:
How taxation muddies the waters of income inequality measures
Emission taxes may undermine corporate investment and do little for the environment